Some Favorite Albums of 2025 (Your Results May Vary)

01 December 2025

Some Favorite Albums of 2025 (Your Results May Vary)

CONTRIBUTED BY GABRIEL DAVID BARKIN | PUBLISHED ON December 1, 2025

Gabriel’s Totally Subjective List of
Favorite Albums Released in 2025

I listen to a wide variety of music. My playlists lean toward alt and classic rock, Americana, and a lot of what we used to call “singer-songwriter” stuff – but I always keep my ears open to explore things in a variety of genres. Just for the record: my “favorites” list for this year includes two re-releases, so it’s not technically all “new” music.

What albums released in 2025 made it onto your “best of” list? Join the conversation on Facebook: CLICK HERE and tell me your favorites.

To qualify for my list, I use a metric roughly similar to longtime Village Voice critic Robert Christgau’s stipulation, which is (a) each song needs to stand on its own merit, and (b) the sum of the parts on the record need to add up to something even more. It has to be something I want to listen to over and over – as  have with all of these albums.

First the list (in no particular order), and then some brief notes on each below:
  1. Sharon Van Etten – Sharon Van Etten & the Attachment Theory
  2. Sam Fender – People Watching
  3. Mdou Moctar – Tears of Injustice
  4. Martha Wainwright – Ground Floor
  5. Youth Lagoon – Rarely Do I Dream
  6. Angela Autumn – I’m Not Around
  7. Fleetwood Mac – Like Crying: The Songs of Danny Kirwan
  8. Ty Segall – Possession
  9. Jesse Welles – Pilgrim
  10. Big Thief – Double Infinity
  11. Geese – Getting Killed
  12. Jeff Tweedy – Twilight Override
  13. The Salt Collective – A Brief History of Blindness

Honorable mentions go to some really great albums that came close but just didn’t quite make the cut – including 2025 releases by The War and Treaty, My Morning Jacket, Greensky Bluegrass, ALO, Hot Buttered Rum, Wednesday, and David Byrne.


Sharon Van Etten – Sharon Van Etten & the Attachment Theory

Photo

An emotional and moving rock album. There’s something eerie about how some of the songs sound sort of the same but take me to completely different places, like pieces of a relationship that include elements of coming together, moving apart, and looking back. The closing song “I Want You Here” is particularly haunting, plaintive and touching.


Sam Fender – People Watching

Photo

Fender is truly a Bruce Springsteen for northern England – a man of the people who channels the economic frustration of the lower class and champions their dreams. This is his third album, and they’re all winners from tip to toe. On “Crumbling Empire,” he sings “I’m not preaching, I’m just talking, I don’t wear the shoes I used to walk in.” (The title came from a cabbie in Detroit, but the song is about his home in a modest port town.) When I saw him at the Fox earlier this year, the audience was 75% Brits who sang every line and ate up every note.


Mdou Moctar – Tears of Injustice

Photo

I saw Moctar’s “Funeral for Justice” album on a lot of year-end “Best of” lists for 2024, but it was a tad too frenetic for me. Happily, Moctar re-recorded the entire record with a somewhat more measured pace and acoustic vibe. IMHO, second time’s the charm.


Martha Wainwright – Ground Floor

Photo

This album was originally released in 1997 by Wainwright on cassette, available only at her live performances.  It is essentially a collection of demo recordings. The album was digitized and rereleased in 2025 – and thank you for that, Ms. Wainwright! It’s a brutally honest collection with poetic lyrics. I particularly like a line in “Precious Smiles”: “He was wearing a ball cap and glasses. I usually hate ball caps with glasses. But I fell in love with him.”


Youth Lagoon – Rarely Do I Dream

Photo

And rarely do I EVER listen to a complete downbeat “indietronica” record – but this one got my attention and latched onto my brain. Trevor Powers wrote and recorded these tracks after finding a trove of his family’s home video in his parents’ basement. The audio from those videotapes is often prominent on the album (including the voice of toddler Trevor), which features mostly downbeat and mellow tunes but with a few louder cuts. Even the singing sounds like ambient techno. It’s musical voyeurism, kind of like watching your new neighbor’s home movies while listening to Portishead.


Angela Autumn – I’m Not Around

Photo

Not unlike Valerie June, Autumn has a voice that croons and yodels with endearing passion. The refrain of “Electric Lizard” is a major earworm – she repeats the line “My fucking lies!” until you just have to believe her. Simple country arrangements with banjo and guitar, a country twang in her voice, and authenticity for miles. (This is an EP technically, but I’m throwing it in anyway.)


Fleetwood Mac – Like Crying: The Songs of Danny Kirwan

Photo

Kirwan joined Fleetwood Mac to add a third guitar (along with Peter Green and Jeremy Spencer) when he was just 18. For over four years, he added a distinctive tremolo sound to the early recordings of the legendary British blues-adjacent band. This lengthy anthology features songs that highlight Kirwan’s contributions. You might recognize “Bare Trees,” but other than that these are mostly deep cuts that only big fans from the early days of the band will know.


Ty Segall – Possession

Photo

Segall has “tried on” many genres over the past decade. This is the only album that has turned me on, a sort of pop-proggy thing that reminds me of Utopia and other Todd Rundgren stuff. Catchy riffs and lyrics. Unfortunately, when I went to see him, his show barely touched this album, and instead he mostly played grungy guitar hero stuff. Which, in Segall’s case, is not bad – but not as interesting.


Jesse Welles – Pilgrim

Photo

Welles released TWO great albums this year. I prefer “Pilgrim.” He’s a gifted lyricist, adept at turning a phrase and sneaking in a rhyme. “I better get to work, ‘cause my boss is a jerk, and bein’ alive costs money.” Ain’t that the truth! Gotta love that smoke-filled, craggy voice too.


Big Thief – Double Infinity

Photo

Nobody crafts more touching, exciting, vibrant Americana rock music than Big Thief. It feels like we’re inside Adrianne Lenker’s heart when she reminisces in “Incomprehensible” and “Los Angeles.” We touch her pain in “All Night All Day” when she sings, “Swallow poison, swallow shit, sometimes it tastes the same.” The music is compelling and psychedelic – the live performance of “No Fear” at the Greek this summer was one of my favorite live moments of the year. I can’t say enough good stuff about this record. It kicks ass.


Geese – Getting Killed

Photo

The New York Times decided to have fun reviewing new albums by both Geese and Goose in the same article recently. There’s no contest here for me. (Goose is awesome live, but the album is a mixed bag IMO.) I stumbled onto Geese opening for Spoon a few years ago, and I was bummed I’d missed the whole set. Singer Cameron Winter has one of the most distinctive voices in rock, kind of like a bastard lovechild of Lou Reed and Captain Beefheart. Once you get past the noisiness of some of the arrangements (and I often like “noisy” anyway), you’ll appreciate the creativity.


(Interestingly, Big Thief and Geese, who made my two favorite rock records of the year, are both from Brooklyn.)


Jeff Tweedy – Twilight Override

Photo

My first impression of this three-disc(!) set by the Wilco frontman was “Some good stuff, but overall quite self-indulgent. Couldn’t he have boiled this down to one disc of the best tracks?” Now that I’ve played it through a few times and seen him play some of these in concert, my lasting impression of this record is: “Masterpiece!” It takes a phenomenal songwriter to produce 30(!) songs that each stand up on their own and also mesh together on one record. Many are deeply introspective and personal cuts.  And “Lou Reed Was My Babysitter,” written about Tweedy’s longing to see live music during the Covid shutdown – even if it meant getting beer spilled on his shoes – is a delightfully anthemic anchor in the midst of many gems.


The Salt Collective  – A Brief History of Blindness

Photo

Salt, a French trio with fewer than 20,000 Spotify listeners as of this writing, collaborated with a dozen or so American singers (including Aimee Mann, Julianna Hatfield, Matthew Sweet, and Nada Surf’s Matthew Caws) to produce this delightful little record. Sounds like jangly rock from the British “French Invasion” era of music (*yes, I made that era up just now), but with more powerful drums and better overall production. Like driving fast on Parisian streets after midnight with the radio cranked. Like, what would it sound like if Air covered a bunch of previously unheard songs from REM and Wings? Fun for the whole family!

# # #

www.gdbarkin.com | IG: @gabrieldavidbarkin

|